Penny U

Penny U

Tuesday, February 10, 2015

Notes: Feb 2 – Inequality and Democracy

The heart of Penny U is conversation based on questions posed as springboards.

Why did we come?

At the beginning of this Penny U, everyone said a few words about what incident or ideas drew them to this conversation. We heard: the Penny U  announcement at James Galbraith's Town Hall talk; changes in the work place; Naomi Klein; Robert Reich; ideas in the book Spirit Level: Why more equal societies almost always do better, by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett; ideas about "post-work," guaranteed income, and democracy inside work places; Town Hall talks by Matt Taibbi and Robert Reich; the film Inequality for All; health disparities; Jane Jacobs' ideas about cities and economies, Lewis Hyde's book The Gift, and "the fact that my husband is an artist."

Questions for the day

The heart of Penny U is conversation based on questions we pose as springboards. This month the questions were:

•    Why is democracy threatened by inequality?  Democracy is defined as "a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly" or "the absence of hereditary or arbitrary class distinctions or privileges." How does economic inequality threaten it? Why does Thomas Piketty believe that extreme inequality threatens democratic institutions, or why did James Galbraith include as one of his reasons for a strong middle class in the 20th century the fact that the "common wealth" was supported, that is, the things we consume in common like the environment, education, culture? Does this, or how does this, get translated into our civic life in Seattle?

•     Are social movements necessary to fighting inequality?  Matt Taibbi lectured this month on this book, The Divide.  In it he juxtaposes the lenience our government has taken towards financial crimes since the great recession with the harsh policing and prosecution of poor communities of color. These injustices, Taibbi argues, inspired the Occupy and Black Lives Matter movements, respectively, and these movements share a common legacy in challenging the status quo of inequality. Are social movements necessary to challenge inequality in this country, and what role do they have to play?

•     What can we do here to address income inequality? Members of the audience asked James Galbraith his advice for Seattle's City Council and local activists about what specifically our city or region can do to address income inequality. He deferred, citing the "Galbraith rule" to never give advice on local politics. What do you think can be done on a local level to address these problems – what can local government do, and what can we as members of our specific communities do?

THE CONVERSATIONS

After the questions were posed, the 15-20 of us present divided into smaller groups around one of the three questions. One person at each table took notes to share here.

What can be done locally to address income inequality?

•     The conversation started with a discussion of $15 wage policies.

•     We have problems getting accurate economic information.

•     The energy has to be concentrated on geographic areas that need social programs, and to be sustainable, communities themselves must be empowered.

•     What is Seattle's economic/cultural heritage?  Boom and bust.

•     Is inequality an issue here? It's important to ask the people suffering from inequality.

Who is the working class?

•     Housing costs push poorer people out to suburban and semi-rural communities.

•     College subsidies through the federal 529 program ultimately serves the wealthy and the connected.

•     Who is the working class?

•     A stark comparison can be made between health care workers in the current structure and blue collar manufacturing workers in the past who earned a living wage and could support a family.

•     Would it be possible for government to raise capital gains tax at the state level in order to make community college education affordable or free?

•     Looking at tax strategy as a solution is perhaps the worst strategy, especially at the national level. When the tax measure to support the bus system failed in King County, that left the cities to close the gaps, which only happened in Seattle.

Can Seattle be a "democracy laboratory"?

•     What will be the impact of district representation in Seattle? Probably more diversity.

•     Can local government in Seattle serve as an effective model to the outside?  Can we be a "democracy laboratory" ?

Are social movements necessary to fighting inequality?

The big answer from this group came early: "Yes, movements are necessary." Then they asked, "What role do movements play?"

•     They're important in how they interact with laws and social norms, for both immediate and long-term impacts.

•     They build visibility & exposure and have an effect on media and politicians.

•     They can leverage media effectively, and use social media to have an influence.

•     What is the role of nonprofits in creating and sustaining the movement? What role must they play? What role do they have to play?

•     Movements are necessary because they become the momentum for change.

•     What emotional states start or are sustaining forces for a movement?

There's power in a movement of diverse people who share a "common enough" focus.

•    There's power when a diversity of people in a movement come together with a "common enough" focus. There's great potential in movements that come from different life experiences, and from different social classes.

•     How can we pull people into a movement who are not totally aligned? That is, how can we align diverse parties, especially across economic differences?

•     The group discussed timing & leadership, spontaneity vs. planning, and leadership & grassroots.

And then they asked, what are the threats to movements?
•     Not having a voice
•     Internal disagreement
•     Feeling impotent
•     Family pressures
•     Future job limitations
•     When good people do nothing.

If they'd had more time, the group would have taken up another question they asked, What are the elements of effective movements?

Why is democracy threatened by inequality?

The group began by discussing the definition of democracy (above) and related terms.

•     What's the difference between democracy and liberalism? Are they connected? Democracy is concerned with power being distributed as broadly as possible. Liberalism aims to protect people against the state (and more). Is this the distinction between a politics that resolves disputes in courts and one that resolves them through debates and movements?

•     And what is a republic? A government where power is not hereditary [and where power resides in representatives of citizens with the power to vote]. Founding Fathers had a fear of hereditary wealth and a fear of the mob. 

•     How does a representative process affect democracy? And how does accountability fit into this? In the early Greek republic, representatives had to give an annual account of their actions to the people who elected them. Could we do that?

•     At the same time, when 27% of the population doesn't vote it means we as citizens aren't taking responsibility for our own power.

How can the responsibility to participate be real and not just a nominal possibility? 

•     Democracy also involves participation and negotiation – the ability to make decisions about things that affect our lives. Many obstacles can prevent people from participating. Historically slavery was a clear exclusion. Today, poverty and too much work can be a barrier. How can the right or responsibility to participate be real and not just a nominal possibility?

•     Isn't the privatization of public services another obstacle?  People take Uber just because they don't want to get on the bus. They are less invested in the public good, in the common wealth. How can we recover a sense of what government can accomplish, of the positive role it can play?

•     When corporations take over, where's democracy then? Is there something called the vote of the market? Can you vote with your money? Can that be democracy? How do we fight that?  Boycotts maybe. Does this constitute unequal voting rights?

Can you vote with your money? Can that be democracy?

•     A condo I had in the past had unequal voting rights based on the square footage and value of your apartment; the higher and larger (hence, more expensive) your apartment, the more your vote was worth. In Athenian democracy, officials were chosen in large part by lottery (from among the small percentage eligible to vote).

•     What can we do to get people who aren't involved now (or who are excluded) to participate? Perhaps because Americans are such an optimistic people that we think, "Some day I'll be rich, so let's just not change things." The reality is that the U.S. has one of the lowest rates of social mobility.

How do we create a belief that collective action will pay off?

•     Organizing is the key, in the workplace and elsewhere. How do we create a belief that collective action will pay off? It can't just be up to each of us as individuals.

Sunday, January 25, 2015

Next Up: Feb 2 – Inequality and democracy

The next Penny U will discuss the relationship between wealth and income, inequality and democracy. The conversation is scheduled to begin at 5:30 pm, on Monday, February 2 in Town Hall’s downstairs cafe. The doors open at 5:00. Join us early for drinks and snacks in the cafe.

By the time we get together on Monday, my co-organizer Edward Wolcher and I will have a few specific questions to spark our conversations. You’re welcome to bring your own as well. In the meantime, what follows is background for the discussion. We hope you can join us!

                                                                                                 – Anne Focke

P.S.  Consider joining us afterward to hear Nikil Saval, whose recent book, Cubed: A Secret History of the Workplace, is an investigation into the way we work and a history of how we got from bookkeepers in dark counting houses to freelancers in bright cafes. <http://townhallseattle.org/event/nikil-saval/>

*

Is inequality the new normal?

One starting point for our conversation will be a Town Hall program a few days before Penny U:

      “Understanding Inequality in America and the World” – James K. Galbraith
      7:30 pm, Town Hall’s Great Hall, Friday, January 30

In his new book, The End of Normal: The Great Crisis and the Future of Growth, Galbraith challenges the view that the economic growth from the early 1950s until 2000 represented the “normal.” A publisher’s statement says:

Today, four factors impede a return to normal. They are the rising costs of real resources, the now-evident futility of military power, the labor-saving consequences of the digital revolution, and the breakdown of law and ethics in the financial sector.… Policies and institutions going forward should be designed, above all, modestly, to cope with this fact, maintaining conditions for a good life in difficult times.

Galbraith argues that unstable economic conditions and the rise of inequality, which we see today, should be regarded as the new normal. And Town Hall’s announcement suggests that he will offer advice on how average citizens can combat this war of economics.

Extreme inequality threatens democracy

Several Penny U participants are taking a class at the Richard Hugo House with Charles Mudede titled, “Thomas Piketty: Capitalism and Lit.” My hope is that they’ll come to Penny U with insights from Piketty’s Capital in the 21st Century.

I’d never pretend to be able to summarize a 700-page book, especially one I haven’t read. But many interviews and reviews I’ve read of Piketty’s book are intriguing in light of the topic of this Penny U. In an article in The Guardian from December 2014, Owen Jones gave a quick summary:

Using a mass of data, the book sought to expose why modern capitalism is an engine of exploding inequality: the rate of return on capital exceeds the rate at which the economy grows, Piketty argues, and wealth is becoming ever more concentrated at the top.

While Piketty seems to say that inequality by itself is acceptable as long as it is in the common interest, according to Steven Erlanger in The New York Times. But Piketty, like economist Joseph Stiglitz, “argues that extreme inequality ‘threatens our democratic institutions.’ Democracy is not just one citizen, one vote, but a promise of equal opportunity.” Erlanger goes on to quote Piketty:

It’s very difficult to make a democratic system work when you have such extreme inequality [in income] and such extreme inequality in terms of political influence and the production of knowledge and information. One of the big lessons of the 20th century is that we don’t need 19th century inequality to grow.”

But Piketty concludes, Erlanger added, “that’s just where the capitalist world is heading again.”

References
           




Saturday, January 24, 2015

Spring Conversations

Save the Dates

On Monday, February 2, Penny U at Town Hall will begin a new three-part series of conversations about the changing nature of work. In general terms, the conversations ask: How are the concepts of jobs and work changing or being redefined? What does our own work experience tell us? What does this mean for the future?

Join us for conversations about these and related questions.

Penny U schedule

5:30 to 7:00 p.m., Town Hall’s downstairs cafe
Doors open at 5:00. Come early for drinks and snacks.

•    Monday, February 2 – Inequality, capital, and democracy
•    Tuesday, March 10 – Climate change and jobs
•    Tuesday, April 7 – Work and the commons

What’s happened so far?  Is there more?

Penny U conversations draw from Town Hall speakers and always begin with questions. Last fall, the first three Penny U sessions asked, in sequence: What kind of work is valued? What is the impact of technology on work? and What’s the state of wages, income, and equality? The third session’s conversation led to another question, What is the fundamental problem underneath our current inequality?

The posts in the Penny U archive include an introduction to each conversation (“Next Up:…”), a report on what happened at each one (“Notes:…”), and a few other related pieces. Notes can’t capture the real energy of the discussion, but they’ll give you a general sense of what we talked about.

Check it out!

Why talk about work? My take.

As we start the second series of Penny U conversations, I’m prompted to pause, take a deep breath, and ask myself why I wanted conversations about work. Everyone starts where they are, and my interest in learning more about work definitely began with my own experience.

For one thing, I wanted to step beyond seeing the “trees” of my work and livelihood and try to understand the “forest” of how my work compares with a societal sense of what work looks like. I want to understand how the way we get a living is changing and why it so often seems like such a struggle.

I could do this by reading, going to lectures, or talking with people who study these things. And I do. But I also want to learn from others about their real-life experiences. I want to hear how you see your work, whether the nature of it is changing, and how you see it fitting into a larger world. And I want to discover new ways of thinking about work and jobs and the economy that could be useful both to me and to others.

Work beyond jobs

When I say “work,” I’m not simply meaning work for pay, important as that is. I mean it more broadly than that. Perhaps my view comes from my early days as an artist when the artists around me made a distinction between “jobs” that paid the bills and their “real work,” that is, their painting or poetry or music. Their work was what they were driven to do, whether it paid or not. Of course everyone wanted to reach a point where the work also put food on the table, but we knew that didn’t happen often. Some time later I realized that many kinds of work – very real and sometimes very hard work – also didn’t pay, or at least didn’t pay well.

Over the decades, I’ve wondered why so much important work is not well paid in our economic and political world, not only artists’ and poets’ work, but the work of caring for young children and aging parents, of coming together to solve community problems or to celebrate, of protecting our common resources, of independent research, philosophy, and invention. Why, when there’s so much work to do, are there so few jobs that pay to do it?

“The end of jobs as we know them”

As soon as I started carrying ideas about work around in my head, the topic seemed to be everywhere.

“The entire concept of  ‘work’ will undergo a significant shift in the next decade,” according to an August 2014 PewResearch study of the impact of technology on the future of jobs. Carl Camden, CEO of Kelly Services, wrote last year, “Some 43% of working Americans don’t have a ‘job’ – they have work and they’re employed, but they don’t work as a traditional ‘employee’.…The way we think about work, and in particular how we define a job, is changing – and it’s changing fast!… Job security is an oxymoron.”

Andy Stern, former president of the SEIU, now at the Columbia Business School, is part of an initiative with the Open Society Foundations that is exploring the Future of Work. In 20-30 years, he says, we’re apt to see “the end of jobs as we know them.” Among other things, we need to “align our economy toward work that is needed and valuable to society, like child care and reducing our carbon footprint.” Paul Mason, economics editor at the UK’s Channel 4 News, also recently said an alternative to our current economic system is needed, “because populations armed with smartphones and an increased sense of their human rights will not accept a future of high inequality and low growth.” 

And certainly in today’s world the dramatic and increasing inequality between the highest and lowest earners and wealth holders is affecting, or will affect, all our lives. A new report from Oxfam [Oxfam news] finds that the combined wealth of the richest 1 percent of the world's population will be greater than that of the other 99 percent by 2016 – that’s just next year!

All in all, there’s much to learn and lots to talk about! 

Join us!

Come join us this spring at Town Hall for a Penny U conversation.